Hi Stephanie.. I will try to help you.. If you mean the elf's paw shards from the elf toy,, then you can change it into blue elf's paw..
First,, go to the elf toy and then touch emblem reedem icon at the top right.. Then touch plus "+" icon at the top right and the explanation will come out.. You can change 50 elf's paw shards (pink) into 1 elf's paw (blue).. If you qualify it then touch redeem button..
Hope my answer can help you.. Good luck :)
What can i get when elf paw cloths are identical? Wasting diamond and gold. Nothing back for identical items is so bad. Plz fix